Homeopathy and the law
EU Regulation on Veterinary Medicines
In March 2016 the EU parliament voted on our amendments to the EU Regulation on Veterinary Medicines. The amendments would have made it possible to use all homeopathic medicinal products registered for human use also in animals as first line treatment in every single country within the EU. Unfortunately, in December 2017 the negative vote of the Council of the EU on our proposed amendments was announced. We managed to talk to many who were involved in the negotiations between the EU parliament, Council of the EU, and EU commission. We were allowed to make our case and were given good feed back from these exchanges. Unfortunately, there were too many countries (representatives of the national health ministeries) who were against our amendments. During the negotiations it was therefore decided to leave the difficult subject of the regulation of the use of (human) homeopathic medicines registered according to EU Directive 2001/83 in animals to national governments in order to be able to finalise the new Veterinary medicines regulation (May 2018).
This returned the regulation of the use of registered (human) homeopathic medicinal products in animals to the national level. This can be seen as a small victory and shows there is sufficient support for homeopathy in the EU decision bodies. Otherwise the use of 'homeopathic medicinal products registered for humans' in animals could not be allowed on national level because an EU regulation is direct law and no national additions or different interpretations would be possible. For now, there are three cases:
Countries with the national law saying homeopathy (registered homeopathic remedies) does not fall under the cascade or where the cascade does not exist. Homeopathy can be used as first line therapy.
Countries with national law saying homeopathy (registered homeopathic remedies) falls under the cascade. Homeopathy cannot be used as first line therapy, BUT, because, according to the EU organic farming regulation saying that homeopathy should be used as first line therapy there is a contradiction between the national law and the EU organic farming regulation. This is valid for farm animals from organic farms.
Countries with national law saying nothing about the use of registered homeopathic remedies. In this case homeopathy cannot be used as first line therapy as it is not stated within the EU Regulation on Veterinary Medicines that homeopathy (registered homeopathic remedies) does not fall under the cascade, BUT according to the EU organic farming regulation saying that homeopathy should be used as first line therapy there is a contradiction between the national law and the EU organic farming regulation. This is valid for farm animals from organic farms.
It is recommended to get in contact with the ministries and agencies in each country and tell them about the contradiction of the national law with the EU organic farming regulation. If the national law is saying that homeopathy falls within the cascade, or if the national law does not say anything about homeopathy and the cascade, tell them the wording of the EU organic farming regulation and that homeopathy (registered homeopathic remedies) should be legally out of the cascade. This is the link to the EU Regulation 2018/848 on Organic Farming in all languages: Regulation (EU) 2018/848 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 30 May 2018 on organic production and labelling of organic products and repealing Council Regulation (EC) No 834/2007
The important wording in the EU Regulation 2018/848 on Organic Farming can be found at Attachment II, Part 2: 220.127.116.11.! Please read also: 18.104.22.168. + 22.214.171.124
126.96.36.199.: Feed materials of mineral origin authorised pursuant to Article 24 for use in organic production, nutritional additives authorised pursuant to Article 24 for use in organic production, and phytotherapeutic and homeopathic products shall be used in preference to treatment with chemically synthesised allopathic veterinary medicinal products, including antibiotics, provided that their therapeutic effect is effective for the species of animal and for the condition for which the treatment is intended. Fortunately, it was managed to keep this wording of preferred use of homeopathy in the EU Regulation on Organic Farming, this might be due to our great lobbying for homeopathy. This EU Regulation was finalized in May this year.
This is the link which should eventually have the EU Regulation COM(2014)0558 on Veterinary Medicines in all languages, but it is a work in progress (as of September 2018 there is essentially nothing there): https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/?qid=1530180158016&uri=CONSIL:ST_9763_2018_ADD_1_COR_1.
The English version can be found below this letter.
Dr. Petra Weiermayer, IAVH Secretary